Free USA Shipping!

The Everlasting Eye Set

202   |  
$55.99 $79.99 You Save 30% ($24.00)

Create a fabulous, waterproof, long lasting look for your eyes and entire face.

The Everlasting Eye Set

A 5 piece waterproof makeup set that you can customize. Select your own colors!
Everlasting Eye Set Includes:

All products are allergy tested, certified cruelty free with PETA, and Made in USA
Please Select Your Shade...
Anna - A Matte Warm Rosy Beige
Elsa - A Pale Shimmering Lilac
Pink Icing - A Pale Pearlized Pink
Crystal - A Pale Shimmering Pewter
Golden Caramel - A Caramel Brown with Golden Shimmer
Duchess - A Peachy Rose with a Silver Sheen
Misty Mocha - A Matte Cool Mocha Beige
Brighten Up - A warm matte cream
Cameo - a light nude pink
Nudetrality - a matte warm nude
Please Select Your Shade...
Black Beauty - Pure black
Chocolate Kiss - Deep brown/black
Sunset - Shimmery copper
Mischievous - Black with green and gold flecks
Amethyst - Deep eggplant
Steel Magnolia - Deep grey with shimmer
Black Orchid - Luscious metallic black burgundy
Chocolate Sizzle - Milk chocolate brown with golden shimmer and golden flecks
Blue Angel - A Classic Navy Blue
Hunter - A Rich Hunter/Forest Green

Customer Reviews

Based on 202 reviews
5 Star
92% 
186
4 Star
5% 
10
3 Star
3% 
6
2 Star
0% 
0
1 Star
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews (202)
  • Questions (0)

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!
KN
06/19/2017
Karen N
Angels Camp, Ca.

Awesome duo

I loved this duo, Elsa and the midnight black with green gold hues. Nice look together. I watched both videos and viola amazing and easy results. Thank you for making my day easier!

UG
12/23/2016
Uma G.
United States

Excellent I love it

Excellent I love it

RG
12/10/2016
Rhonda G.
United States

Great product

I usually have raccoon eyes by the end of the day due to my oily skin. This eyeliner is awesome !!! No more raccoon eyes for me

MM
11/10/2016
Meichelle M.
United States

Oh my goshhh I love this stuff!!

This is the second or third time Ive ordered Stay Put Gel Eyeliner and I must say that had been in search for a long lasting and staying liner for an extremely long time as I am not a primper and dont have time to fuss so much with my make up through the day. This stuff works so well and stays so long that if I dont take it off the night before often it's still on the next morning lol.. Ok, so Im guilty, I tend to do this too often haha.. I simply love the color, I love the feel on my eyes, as if Im wearing nothing.. And I repeatedly keep getting wonderful compliments on my eyes. I cant say enough great things about Mommy MakeUp's Stay Put Gel Eyeliner! Ive tried four different colors so far and love each of them! I'll defin be a very long standing customer!! Meichelle M.

DG
10/03/2016
Darlene G.
United States

Fantastic gel eye liner

This is without a doubt the best eyeliner ever

Questions & Answers