Shop Now. Pay Later. Installments by

 Afterpay. Pay for your purchase over four equal installments, due every two weeks. Allows you to pay over time.

The Everlasting Eye Set

205   |  
$55.99 $79.99 You Save 30% ($24.00)

Please Select Your Shade...
Anna - A Matte Warm Rosy Beige
Elsa - A Pale Shimmering Lilac
Pink Icing - A Pale Pearlized Pink
Crystal - A Pale Shimmering Pewter
Golden Caramel - A Caramel Brown with Golden Shimmer
Duchess - A Peachy Rose with a Silver Sheen
Misty Mocha - A Matte Cool Mocha Beige
Brighten Up - A warm matte cream
Cameo - a light nude pink
Nudetrality - a matte warm nude
Please Select Your Shade...
Black Beauty - Pure black
Chocolate Kiss - Deep brown/black
Mischievous - Black with green and gold flecks
Amethyst - Deep eggplant
Steel Magnolia - Deep grey with shimmer
Black Orchid - Luscious metallic black burgundy
Chocolate Sizzle - Milk chocolate brown with golden shimmer and golden flecks
Blue Angel - A Classic Navy Blue
Hunter - A Rich Hunter/Forest Green

Create a fabulous, waterproof, long lasting look for your eyes and entire face.

The Everlasting Eye Set

A 5 piece waterproof makeup set that you can customize. Select your own colors!
Everlasting Eye Set Includes:

All products are allergy tested, certified cruelty free with PETA, and Made in USA

Customer Reviews

Based on 205 reviews
5 Star
4 Star
3 Star
2 Star
1 Star
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Monique R.
United States

Not quite it

I ordered the set and the brown is nice but the caramel is too light so I can’t see myself using it at all so that is a waste


Simply gorgeous

This was either my 5th or 6th order. And again Debra does not disappoint! I received the Elsa and Blue Angel combo and let me tell you my eyes look whiter and so beautiful! The Blue Angel is such an unusual shade. It's not Navy it's not Royal it's not purple but yet a combination of all the above. And the brushes amazing! I'm hooked!

Mary J.
United States

New makeup

I am 68 years old and I absolutely love this makeup. I love the eyeliner and mascara. Everything is easy to apply. I am in love with this product.

Karen N
Angels Camp, Ca.

Awesome duo

I loved this duo, Elsa and the midnight black with green gold hues. Nice look together. I watched both videos and viola amazing and easy results. Thank you for making my day easier!

Uma G.
United States

Excellent I love it

Excellent I love it

Rhonda G.
United States

Great product

I usually have raccoon eyes by the end of the day due to my oily skin. This eyeliner is awesome !!! No more raccoon eyes for me

Meichelle M.
United States

Oh my goshhh I love this stuff!!

This is the second or third time Ive ordered Stay Put Gel Eyeliner and I must say that had been in search for a long lasting and staying liner for an extremely long time as I am not a primper and dont have time to fuss so much with my make up through the day. This stuff works so well and stays so long that if I dont take it off the night before often it's still on the next morning lol.. Ok, so Im guilty, I tend to do this too often haha.. I simply love the color, I love the feel on my eyes, as if Im wearing nothing.. And I repeatedly keep getting wonderful compliments on my eyes. I cant say enough great things about Mommy MakeUp's Stay Put Gel Eyeliner! Ive tried four different colors so far and love each of them! I'll defin be a very long standing customer!! Meichelle M.

Darlene G.
United States

Fantastic gel eye liner

This is without a doubt the best eyeliner ever

Christine A.

Best Eyeliner Ever

Every liner I used in the past, burned my eyes whenever I would get some on the water line. Mommy Makeup gel eyeliner goes on easily, doesn't run and NEVER, EVER burns. I truly love this product.

Sara R.
United States

Fitness mommy review

I've been trying to find a replacement for my buxom cream shadow that was discontinued. The makeup stays on well. With that said, it needs a little improvement. I use cream blending brushes, and I still wish it would blend better. I wish it had a more shimmer to it. It is good, but still not as good as my desired buxom cream shadow.

Cynthia G.
United States

Nice and easy

So quick and easy!!! A little goes a long way.

Allen, V.
United States

Forever stays.

Forever stays.

Questions & Answers